Point/Counterpoint: Gunny, I’m not sure I understand vs. Message to Garcia, Devil Dog!

marine gunny target shooting

The following is a Point/Counterpoint between a Marine lance corporal and his gunnery sergeant concerning assigned tasks and duties.

The Point is presented by Lance Cpl. Dusty Carmichael, and the counterpoint is presented by Gunnery Sgt. Luis Hernandezhernandez-Vandecampschultz.

Point: Gunny, I’ve been given this task but I’m not sure about…

Counterpoint: Message To Garcia there, Devil Dog! Make it happen!

Point: Ok, but…

Counterpoint: But nothin’! You’re cleared hot! Message To Garcia leatherneck! Get it done!

Point: Aye Gunny, but I don’t understand…

Counterpoint: What I don’t understand is why you’re still standing here wasting Marine Corps time! This is a Message To Garcia operation! Helloooooooo!

Point: Um, have you even read the book? There’s a reason the Commandant took it off the reading list.

Counterpoint: You insubordinate bastard! You don’t know shit! Men like Garcia made Marine Corps history and you’re standing around with your hands in your pockets!

Point: I don’t think anyone in the story was even in the Marine Corps, Gunny. Wasn’t Garcia a Cuban general?

Counterpoint: The Cubans are friggin’ Communists! What the hell is wrong with you? Message To Garcia! Message To Garciaaaaaaa!

Point: Gunny, I’m just asking for a little guidance here.

Counterpoint: I will guide my foot directly into your ass shit-bird! You’re giving me excuses when you should attack, attack, attack! Message! To! Garcia!

Point: Oh my God, I can’t wait until I EAS.

Counterpoint: You’re not reenlisting? You traitorous sonofabitch!

Can you help us? We aren't some gigantic media corporation. Duffel Blog is literally just one guy editing a bunch of articles written by military contributors — all on a shoestring budget. If you love what we do, please donate a few bucks to keep our doors open. Even the smallest amount is a big help.


  1. Yeah, I responded to a seniors review of this book on a blog at work. I’m now expressly forbidden from blogs at work.

  2. I have fond memories of Sgt. Luis Hernandezhernandez-Vandecampschultz. I’m glad to see he’s still doing well…

uss trump

Trump to repurpose USS Enterprise into floating hotel and casino

marine studying book

Controversial new charity teaches veterans how to use GI Bill, go to college, and get a job